Performance Reviews

Management/Supervisor Issues, Performance Reviews

Say It To My Face – What To Do When Your Boss Gives You Great Feedback In Person & A Bad Review On Paper

My manager likes to discuss our performance reviews before he fills out the official evaluation form. During our conversation, his feedback was all very positive, with no negative comments. However, on my written review, I was shocked to find a below average rating for communication skills. Why would he praise me to my face, then criticize me on the form?